Tight or loose coupling for a differential pair?

Both can be 100 Ω, and over a solid plane the pair works either way. Choose the gap for tolerance. On an OSH Park 4-layer board a 100 Ω pair is 0.179 mm wide at a 0.1 mm gap, or 0.325 mm wide at a 0.3 mm gap.

The tight pair is the fragile one. A 0.025 mm etching error on its gap moves it from 91 to 107 Ω, and where its traces split 1 mm apart to pass a via it jumps to 146 Ω. The loose pair moves about 1 Ω with the same gap error and reaches 110 Ω when split.

Use the loosest gap your routing allows, keep it constant, keep any split short and symmetric, and give your fabricator a tolerance on the gap as well as the width.